May the Force be with you
|by Anne Morse|
I've been reading Arthur Brooks's new book, Who Really Cares: Who Gives, Who Doesn't, and Why It Matters (Chuck will be talking about this in an upcoming BreakPoint).
Much of this book's subject matter has been discussed in the news, but here is a point that has not: The effect of welfare reform on charitable giving. Brooks cites evidence that people, when they get off welfare, tend to give more to charity and volunteer their time. But, Brooks asks, "Is leaving welfare the reason these people gave and volunteered more? Perhaps the people most likely to give time and money to charity are the people most likely to get off welfare in the first place. In other words, there might be a force out there that makes needy people both charitable and resistant to long-term welfare dependency. A good candidate for such a force is religion."
As Brooks notes, "We already know that [religion] makes people more generous than they otherwise would be. It might make them more self-reliant as well . . ..This evidence would come as no surprise to many religious social service organizations" that apply "religious faith in the rehabilitation of criminals and drug abusers."
Take, for instance, Prison Fellowship's InnerChange Freedom Initiative. Brooks does. Although he doesn't mention IFI by name in the body of the book, he does in his notes. As he writes in Chapter 4:
One typical organization that uses Christian faith in providing job and life skills to prison inmates describes its programs as "anchored in biblical teaching that stresses personal responsibility, the value of education and work, care of persons and property and the reality of a new life in Christ." Just as faith helps former criminals become productive citizens, it might help resolve the problems leading some people to need welfare in the first place.
Which brings to mind the Americans United lawsuit against PF's IFI program. Perhaps we could get Mr. Brooks to write an amicus brief in support of allowing InnerChange to continue to do its good work in Iowa prisons: transforming the lives of hardened criminals. Oh, wait, I forgot: For secular liberals, it's not about what works; it's not about what's good for society; it's about shutting down the Church--and then accusing Christ's followers of being selfish and greedy.